New England Psychologist - nepsy.com Banner Ad
An Independent Voice for the State's Psychologist
Psy Jobs CE Listings Archives Contact
HomeColumnsBook ReviewsHospital DirectoryAdvertisingClassifiedsAbout Us

Change to clearances aims to encourage troops to seek help
(July 2008 Issue)

By Ami Albernaz

The Pentagon recently amended a questionnaire for security clearances so that applicants would not need to acknowledge all psychological care they have received. Officials feared a question about mental health treatment was deterring soldiers from seeking counseling.

With high numbers of soldiers returning from Iraq and Afghanistan with combat-related anxiety, depression and readjustment difficulties, the change is one of a number of measures that have been taken to encourage troops to seek out mental health counseling. Surveys of soldiers showed they feared acknowledging mental health treatment would jeopardize their security clearances, which are needed for many military positions.

Some who work with soldiers say changing the question is a step in the right direction. Maryann Gnys, Ph.D., associate chief of mental health and behavioral sciences services with the Providence division of VA New England, says younger troops in particular are sometimes reluctant to seek counseling, "since they fear it could hurt their career."

Prior to mid-April, applicants were asked if they had seen a mental health professional in the past seven years and to list treatment details. Cases in which therapy was sought for marriage or grief and was not related to violent behavior, did not have to be reported. Now, troops also no longer have to acknowledge treatment for combat-related difficulties.

The Department of Defense declined comment on the move, though in a briefing available on the department's Web site, Col. Patricia Horoho, R.N., M.S.N, M.S., commander of the Walter Reed Health Care System, said "psychological health is no different from physical health care," and that service members should be encouraged to "maintain their psychological health."

Col. Jonathan Coffin, M.S., the outpatient director of the Howard Center for Human Services in Burlington, Vt., says the Pentagon's action sends a valuable message.

"In general, the best attempts are being made to take down barriers, so that people can feel like they're good soldiers if they get mental health care," he says.

Still, he adds, soldiers might continue to seek out counseling centers they see as being the most discreet. Some in Vermont have turned to the state's veterans'centers, which are smaller than VA medical centers and may be seen as less intimidating.

In Rhode Island, Gnys notes, psychologists and social workers are available in some of the same facilities as primary care doctors. "We try to make [counseling] services available wherever vets might drop in," she says, adding that she sees this sort of holistic care as the future of health services for soldiers.

Counselors also meet with soldiers in Rhode Island upon their return from deployment, Gnys says, which might also help soldiers to feel that counseling is routine.

"Meeting everyone helps people not feel singled out," Gnys says.

Other measures have been proposed to integrate physical and psychological care and remove any stigma associated with counseling. In late April, U.S. Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.) introduced the National Guard and Reserve Mental Health Access Act, which would establish a national network of mental health providers for soldiers (see "Bill would expand services for National Guard, reservists").